Nakagami Disqualification - Team Had Used Filter Since 2012 Without Comment
The Idemistu Honda Team Asia today issued a press release with a clarification on Takaaki Nakagami's disqualification after the Moto2 race at Losail. Nakagami's Kalex was found to be fitted with an illegal air filter during a technical inspection, as Race Director Mike Webb explained to the MotoGP.com website. Webb acknowledged that the error was entirely unintentional, and was a result of misinterpreting the technical rules.
Tady Okada, the former 500GP racer winner who now runs Idemitsu Team Asia, explained in the press release that they had failed to interpret the rules correctly. At the time the team took part in the first test, at the end of 2012, the foam air filter which is part of the HRC race kit was legal. The team fitted this part for testing, and continued to use the part throughout the 2013 season and the first race of 2014. However, for the 2013 season, the use of a standard paper filter was made compulsory, and the use of the foam filter was banned.
The team's use of the foam filter went undetected in 2013, as neither Yuki Takahashi nor the man brought in to replace him, Aslan Shah, managed to score any points. When Takaaki Nakagami got on the podium during his first outing of the season, his bike was subjected to an automatic inspection by the technical scrutineers. The use of the filter was spotted immediately, and an automatic disqualification followed, the rules leaving no room for interpretation. ' In technical issues it’s black and white, it either passes the test or it doesn’t, and it didn’t pass, it’s not within the specification so there is no choice. It’s disqualification,' Mike Webb told MotoGP.com.
The team accepted the disqualification, but in the press release, they say their confusion stems in part from the wording of the rules, and the diagrams used to explain them. The diagrams issued by IRTA, the team claims, come from the papers supplied with the HRC race kit. The team believed that this meant use of the HRC race kit and foam filter was therefore still legal.
The press release issued by Idemitsu Honda Team Asia is show below:
Usage of a non-regulation air intake system at the opening round in Qatar
To those concerned,
The opening round of the 2014 Moto2 World Championship was held in Qatar on March 23 in 2014.
The team, under new team structure, has started out a great start since the winter tests at Valencia and Jerez in Spain on February to set out a victory at the first Grand Prix in Qatar.
The team, which established last year, has earned a pleasing first ever Championship points and the second place. But after the race a technical control detected Nakagami’s bike the use of a non-regulation air intake system. Then the team has been handed Nakagami’s disqualification.
We sincerely apologize for this consequence for Sponsors, our supporter and fans.
The statement which has been pointed, the team conflict with the breach FIM Road Racing World Championship Grand Prix Regulations 184.108.40.206.10. (Airbox: Only the standard airbox supplied by the official Supplier (including air filter and secondary injectors) may be used. No modifications, alterations or additions to this airbox is allowed, expect as described in Art 220.127.116.11.11 below). The fact is the team has used a Race kit (a sponge type air filter) which is sold by Honda Racing Corporation instead of an air filter of the air filter of the production machine Honda CBR600RR.
The team acknowledged that the sponge type of air filter from HRC Race kit was allowed to use according to the information International Racing Team Association (See following page within the framework of red).
The team followed the decision of the Race Direction to obliged to use the standard airbox supplied.
However, this regulation and the information from IRTA are conflicting and difficult to comprehend. Therefore, the team will suggest to ITRA to provide teams an understandable information.
The whole team staff work will make concerned effort. We would appreciate for your continued support.
Information from IRTA and its ART
According to FIM Road Racing World Championship Grand Prix Regulations, the airbox supplied by IRTA which may be used (See Art.1 and Art.2 in the framework of red).
Art.1: Diagram of the HondaCBR600RR air cleaner box
Art.2: Race kit parts (Art.1 in the framework of red) IRTA use the diagram of HRC Race kit parts
- HRC air cleaner of the HRC Race kit parts is a sponge type.
- Supplied product according to the Race regulations is a paper type of Honda CBR600RR
Art.3: The parts (Air filter) which was pointed -> Same diagram with Art.2
Context of the misunderstanding of the team
Arise from a lack of regulations understanding
- The regulations define to obliged to use a paper type air cleaner box form 2013.
- The team continued to use the HRC Race kit since tests in the end of 2012, at the time of the inauguration of the team.
Lack of the information from IRTA
- Replaced to Race Kit seems to allow to use HRC Race kit and the team in fact used.
- The diagram which IRTA used (Diagram from HRC Race kit) caused to bring about the mess.
- There is no parts number indication.
Suggestion to IRTA from the team
- The team will suggest to IRTA to add to write about description within the framework in red that ONLY air funnel is allowed to replace and write about parts number.