Sylvain Guintoli Punished For Using 2020 Engine Spec At Motegi

Sylvain Guintoli has been disqualified for the FP1 and FP2 sessions of the Motegi MotoGP round, after having been found to have used an illegal spec of engine. As a result, all of his times set in FP1 and FP2 have been scrapped, and Guintoli listed as having set no time. Guintoli does still qualify for Q1, having set a time within 107% of the fastest rider in FP3.

The punishment came after Sylvain Guintoli used a prototype of the 2020 Suzuki GSX-RR during his third wildcard appearance. That is in contravention of the rules, specifically rule 2.4.6.2, which states that wildcards must abide by the engine specification rules which apply to all manufacturers. In the case of Suzuki, who are not a concessions team, and so are not allowed to change engine specifications during the season, this means that Guintoli is bound to use the same specification of engine for the whole 2019 season.

But there is some ambiguity in the rules, especially as they apply to wildcards. Each manufacturer is also allowed to run 3 different engine specifications in each season, to allow them to supply satellite teams with different engine specs to the factory squad. And wildcard riders are allowed to use three engines of the same specification at each race, effectively freeing them from the restrictions on the number of engine used by full-time riders in the season.

If this had happened last year, Guintoli would not have been punished. Suzuki was a so-called concessions team during the 2018 season, after failing to score a single podium through 2017. That allowed Guintoli as wildcard to use different engine specs throughout 2018. But after their successful season in 2018, where Alex Rins and Andrea Iannone scoring 9 podiums between them, Suzuki lost their concessions and were stuck with a single engine specification for the entire season for each rider.

The punishment for Suzuki is not because they used a 2020-spec engine, but because the engine spec differs from the one used by Guintoli earlier in the season. If the same thing had happened to Aprilia or KTM, for example, they would not have been punished, as they are allowed to change engine specs as concession teams.

Back to top

Comments

Does it matter that Guintoli got disqualified? He's testing, not racing, so I don't think it does as Suzuki got to test the engine in the real world, not just on a dyno.

Total votes: 18

Seems like this wasn't Guintoli's decision alone ... as rider, yes, he should be penalized, but how about Suzuki as a team/manufacturer? From a MotoGP rules perspective, do they have any liability?

Total votes: 20

So Guintoli is punished ? Is he ? Is Suzuki punished ?

"Oh no, we wanted to try our new 2020 engine during a 2019 race WE and we did but now the laptimes we did are no longer official. Now we do not know if the 2020 engine is working or not because we do not know the laptimes"

I think in the future we will be seing a lot more wild-cards using different engine specs during the same year from non-concessions manufacturers if the punishment remains this silly.

 

Total votes: 16

Who cares, I mean really. They're already reducing official testing, so why not let the wildcards run what ever spec engine.

Total votes: 13