2016 Phillip Island MotoGP Friday Round Up - Rossi's Tire Troubles, Lorenzo's Woes in the Rain

Though I am not one to blow my own trumpet, my Phillip Island preview turned out to be prophetic. (Of course, it helped that my prediction was written just a few hours before the start of practice in Australia.) The Southern Ocean imposed its will on the Australian Grand Prix, and heavy rain and strong winds hampered morning practice, then caused the afternoon practice to be called off.

All three classes used their sessions in the morning, and the Moto3 class set off boldly for FP2, despite worsening conditions. They battled through to an increasingly damp finish, but the rain intensified, postponing MotoGP FP2 for some 40 minutes. Eventually, the session was given the green light, but only a few riders went out to attempt a few laps. After thirteen minutes, Race Direction decided it was too dangerous. FP2 was red-flagged, and all action canceled for the rest of the day.

The poor weather made most of the day's action meaningless, but it also had an upside. Hector Barbera finished the red-flagged FP2 session as fastest, while Mike Jones, his replacement in the Avintia team ending in second. Whatever the circumstances of the session, that goes down in the record books forever. Just as Josh Hayes timed his fast lap in morning warm up at Valencia in 2011 to perfection, and ended up quickest, Mike Jones can say he was second fastest in a MotoGP practice.

The weather gods intervene

The loss of practice for MotoGP and Moto2 will now have to be compensated. Practice starts an hour earlier than scheduled for Moto3, while both MotoGP and Moto2 have been given an extra 15 minutes of practice for FP3, meaning they will both have a whole hour. Even though rain is still forecast to fall, that should be long enough to put in some decent laps, and sort out who gets directly into Q2.

For at the moment, things are a little topsy turvy. Worsening weather meant that the fastest times were set in FP1, especially in the first quarter of an hour. Those who went out early got a good shot at a decent time; those who waited ended up at the tail end of the timesheets, as the track got wetter and three or four seconds slower.

With conditions so wet, there are the names you might expect to see at the front. Brno winner Cal Crutchlow topped FP1, ahead of wet-weather podium man Danilo Petrucci and Assen victor Jack Miller. Marc Márquez ended fourth, ahead of Andrea Dovizioso and Maverick Viñales.

Rules, tires, confusion

Valentino Rossi had ended the session in second place, but his time was taken away from him after it turned out he had put in more than ten laps on the extra soft rain tire, in contradiction to the instructions from Michelin. That was a rather harsh punishment, and one which Rossi disagreed with. "They say to me, 'you have to do maximum ten laps'. And I did nine laps. The problem is that they count also the out lap and in lap, so it became eleven and they **** all my run," he said afterwards.

Where the fault lies is not immediately evident, though it would be reasonable to suspect that this was a miscommunication. The teams were told they could not do ten consecutive laps on the extra soft front, and the interpretation of that rule seems to be where it all went wrong. Rossi and his team assumed that it meant ten flying laps, whereas Race Direction are interpreting it as ten laps including the in and out lap.

Stop me if you've heard this one before

There is a small irony here, of course. Throughout his career, Marc Márquez has been accused of copying Valentino Rossi – the pass at The Corkscrew at Laguna Seca, and the pass in the final corner at Jerez are most often mentioned – but this time, Rossi copied Márquez. In 2013, at Phillip Island, it was Márquez who got punished for doing too many laps on a tire. Márquez definitely came off worse, though, as in 2013, he was black-flagged in the race, after Bridgestone brought a rear tire that was not able to handle the newly resurfaced Phillip Island.

Speaking to the press, Michelin's Nicolas Goubert put the confusion down to the way the rules are for the single tire supplier. When they bring tires to a race, they either have to be capable of full race distance, or be limited to a given number of laps. For rain tires, that can be especially complicated: conditions in the rain can vary wildly, depending on the amount of water on the track and ambient temperatures.

That was the case for the extra soft tire, it seems. Michelin had brought it as a safety tire, knowing how tricky conditions can be at the circuit. But they had underestimated the amount of rain the Southern Ocean can dump on the circuit, and that had given the tire more life. "If the conditions stay as they were this morning, for sure you can do 30 laps," Goubert told reporters. If a similar situation occurred in the future, Michelin would look at lifting the ten-lap limit, he said. But with memories of what happened with a similar tire at Brno, they were loath to do that this weekend.

Simple solution: stop bowing for F1

A simpler remedy to the situation would be to hold the MotoGP race at a different time of year, something which Valentino Rossi pressed for strongly. "I am one of the riders that push more to change the date of this Grand Prix," he told reporters, "because it is a shame to come here in the winter. Particularly because it's a great track, and if you have the sun – for television, also for riding the bike – it's something fantastic for MotoGP."

"I push a lot, but Carmelo always say to me it is impossible to modify the date because the Formula One is in March," Rossi said. Both the F1 Grand Prix and MotoGP are run the Australian Grand Prix Corporation, and they do not want to have their two big events back to back. That is not a decision Rossi agrees with. "Is a shame because for example in Japan this happens," Rossi said. "So one week is Formula One and the next MotoGP. And this year also in Italy: Monza - Misano. Full of people, everything is good. I think it's a good idea to come here to open the championship in March or after Qatar, when have good weather. I try, but I don’t have enough power."

Perhaps the bigger stumbling block is the Grand Prix at Qatar, though. The Losail International Circuit pays a huge premium – around double the usual fee – for the right to organize the opening race of each MotoGP season. There is a good reason for that: if Qatar were at a different time of year, then it would generate far less interest. With the race just one facet of Qatar's attempts to promote itself as a haven for sports, and gloss over its appalling record on treating foreign workers, they need all the attention they can get.

The rain holds demons

Valentino Rossi's demotion put him down to twentieth place, one place behind his teammate, Jorge Lorenzo. The Spaniard's lap times were dismal, ending the session nearly 4.7 seconds off the pace of fastest man Crutchlow. Lorenzo himself played down his slow times, saying he went on track late, and only did a few laps before the weather got worse. "Not so many conclusions, not so much push, not so many risks," he said.

There may be some merit in that argument, but it is also true that while Lorenzo was lapping in the 1'45s, that was the time that many of the riders were putting in their fastest laps, some three or four seconds faster. Perhaps this is a sign that Lorenzo is still carrying a rain monkey on his back, fearing the feeling in wet weather. Yet at the Sachsenring and Brno, both wet races, he reported making big strides forward. That progress is borne out by the timesheets, though not in the results, other factors coming into play. Whether the rain is still Lorenzo's bogey man will have to be seen.


Gathering the background information for long articles such as these is an expensive and time-consuming operation. If you enjoyed this article, please consider supporting MotoMatters.com. You can help by either taking out a subscription, buying the beautiful MotoMatters.com 2016 racing calendar, by making a donation, or by contributing via our GoFundMe page.

Source: 

Back to top

Comments

David, as I posted in your social media, the issue with the start date is/was that Qatar paid for the rights to be the first race. As far as I remember this is also the reason we sent race until April, when the wreather in the desert is predictable enough to prevent dew and the chance of rain (because when it does rain, it rains at the time the gp was supposed to be held). 

Between MM and VR in this specific case: if my memory serves me well MM was asked to pit and just ignored it thus getting black flagged.
On the other hand VR stayed within the requested 9 laps excluding the in and out. I understand rules are rules but if the regulation sheet does not specify clearly which laps to count, well then they cannot punish him. You cannot ignore the rule but the rule has to be clear!
This could have serious consequences : if the weather does not improve he'll have to go through Q1 which is unfair. Given the lack of clarity they should have canceled all laps after the 9th lap but not all of them
Im still puzzled as to why bringing those tires if they cannot be used? Are they planning a flag to flag? If so did they bring enough of those?
True: one of the most stunning circuits deserves to be raced in the best season and not when it's almost certain that hell can break loose at any moment.

I appreciate Mr. Emmett's humor and definitely think the situations are similar.  Your memory is wrong in this instance. MM and his team made a miscalculation on when to pit.  That's straight from what MM and Honda said after the race.  They thought, incorrectly, that they could do 10 laps and then pit.  The ruling was that not more than 10 laps can be completed on one tire.  Seemed simple to me, but what Honda thought was that the lap coming into the pits didn't count as a lap so they would be ok.  So he got the message to pit, but it was given one lap to late.  Stupid mistake for the team to make, but they made it as a team.   I also remember reading that the change in race distance and mandatory pitting was not communicated well, and it also wasn't clear what the penalty would be if that rule was broken.   Change in rules about lap distance on tires, poor communication about change in rules, rider suffers penalty because of misunderstanding of rules.  Sounds similar to me.  And after the results of today's FP3, no ill effect on Rossi's qualifying status.  

I thought Ant West was subbing for Remy Gardner this weekend because Remy has been banged up in a Japanese slammer for being somewhere in the vicinity of Wayne having a moment of irascibility?

Wayne is still in Japan, Remy was released and flew home just in time to take part in practice.

And Ant was, rightfully, pissed that he'd spent 36 hours travelling from Madrid to PI on his own dime, only to arrive and be told that he wasn't racing.

At the rate he's going, if he sticks around the paddock then he might get a ride next time someone comes off.

It doesn't matter what time of year it is, the Island will always be the Island weather wise. Melbourne in general has always been considered our "4-seasons in one day" capital, and PI does itself no favours by venturing even further south.

Valentino is also wrong to assume that it is winter in October/November over here. It's actually our late Spring turning Summer.

You'll get a few degrees more ambient in Dec-Jan-Feb-Mar for sure, but if you think you'll avoid the cold, the wet and the wind - you're wrong. The MotoGP season simply does not start early enough to reap the full benefits of a calendar shift.

PI often mixes championship deciding races with unpredictable weather, breathtaking scenery and some of the quickest twisties on the planet. What's not to like (if you're not Valentino Rossi that is)?

Leave our annual pilgrimage alone please :)

Side note:- How many times have you made it down here now, David? You should definitely consider putting it on your permanent list of events to cover live from track side each year!

Cheers

Never mind the things that are hard to change, how about changing the things that are EASY to change, like running the race at a sensible time of the day!  In a place prone to cold weather at the best of times, running the biggest race of the day when conditions are almost always rapidly cooling is crazy.  It is a reasonably recent change and has already caused numerous crashes in 2014 (safety anyone?).

The fact that this is done only so the Spanish don't have to get out of bed before 7am is the height of lunacy and a perfect demonstration of how horribly skewed the MotoGP world is.  Set your alarm or buy a PVR you lazy so-and-so's!

PS- I'll second Damo in that the weather is ALWAYS unpredictable down there.  I've been going there for 24 years at various times of the year and you can get horrid weather all year round - even in January!  I have long advocated that the whole Island should be dragged up the coast to somewhere arond Nowra.

Have been to the PI International Island Chalenge in late Feb, for the previous five years, have been burnt to a crisp to having my bollcks frozen off! That is the range of the weather at PI!

The WSBK at PI in mid/late March, guanranteed rain every morning over this weekend!

My posts not posting?

 

edit

I tried unsuccessfully to post lat night but for what ever reason my post just didn't appear even though I received the message that they had.

Not to worry, I tried again and this post was successful.

Can admin delete this post as my below post was successful. 

Cheers 

One of the mantras I remember from school is, never assume anything, as it makes an ass out of you and an idiot out of me.

Teams make mistakes, as do riders.

Accept it. Don't wine about the rules or your understanding of them.

The only reason we are talking about this is because the rider involved is Rossi.

If it had been any other rider it would only be mentioned in jest, as come on, how hard is it to count to 10.